Topical Anesthesia vs. Peribulbar or Retrobulbar Blocks in Cataract Surgery

July 27, 2012

I still do peribulbar (actually, the anesthesiologist does it for me), so when i enter the O.R., the eye sees and feels nothing and doesn’t move. I don’t have to nag the patient to look anywhere, like my residents do. Of course, with coumadin cases, I’ll do topical or sub-Tenon’s. Anyway, a meta-analysis by Dr. Zhu in Ophthalmology showed that topical is more painful than retrobulbar (about equal to peribulbar) – BUT, they excluded those topical cases using intracameral lidocaine, so in my opinion, the study is fatally flawed for practical purposes.

 

 



Comments

Jump down to form below to submit your own comments

2 Responses to “Topical Anesthesia vs. Peribulbar or Retrobulbar Blocks in Cataract Surgery”

  1. Isaac Porter, MD on July 27th, 2012 10:47 am

    I perform topical cataract surgery with intracameral lidocaine. I agree with you that it would be interesting to see the data comparing topical with lidocaine to injection anesthesia.

    It’s completely anecdotal but my uncle had a couple of months of diplopia after cataract surgery with a block. He recovered completely but had difficulty when the diplopia was present. I know it’s a risk but don’t know the incidence.

    Ultimately, we all want our patients to be as comfortable as possible during surgery.

  2. ari on July 27th, 2012 1:03 pm

    yeah- diplopia is a very small risk. ive seen it a couple of times. it can be reduced even further by not using marcaine, but only lidocaine- seems the marcaine is toxic if injected into the extraocular muscle, but not lidocaine.

Trackback URL
http://eyedocnews.com/006744-topical-more-painful-but-well-tolerated/trackback/

Have insights to contribute? Please submit your comment below